How to Price Sports Cards

How do you price sports cards?

It’s a question that many collectors ask themselves, and the answer isn’t always clear. The truth is that there are many different factors involved in how much a card should cost, but here are some guidelines to follow when pricing your cards.

  • The player
  • The Cards rarity
  • How much money do you want to make from selling your cards? If you’re looking for quick cash, then lower prices might be the way to go. If you’re trying to sell them for more than double what they were worth originally, then higher prices will probably work better for you!
  • How rare is the card? The more common a card is, the less it’s going to be worth; on the other hand

In this article, we’ll look at some of the best ways to price sports cards.

What’s The Best Way To Check Sports Card Prices?

Later on in this article, we’ll look at what factors impact card prices – but are you supposed to know all that off-by-heart and be able to make educated guesses at price-ranges.

Hell no… 

There’s plenty of ways to see what cards like yours are selling for and what they’ve sold for in the past.

The best way to see the price of your cards is to check previous sales data. As most cards are sold online these days, you can easily find the sales prices from popular card sites.

Here are a few of my favorite ways to check card price.

The Best Option: Market Movers

Market Movers (use the code SCR20 for 20% off) is the card price checking tool from Sports Cards Investor and is my favorite option for those who are serious about their cards.

I’m not going to lie, when Market Movers first came out I rolled my eyes a little. However, they keep improving the tool and it’s now quite a robust way to keep track of a busy card portfolio – along with checking card price.


Market Movers has a lot of positives to it that I know you’ll like.

  • Keep track of card prices over time. You can see pricing trends easily and check if card selling prices are going up or down
  • Compare cards on the same chart. If you want to compare two players’ cards, or even two cards of the same player you can do that to see how they’re performing. A great way to keep track of an entire draft class.
  • Chart any card, or sealed wax
  • You can keep track of sales volume – so not just what price a card is selling for – but how many are selling
  • Set price change alerts. This is cool when you’re looking to either buy or sell. You can set a low price on cards you’re looking to buy, that way, when a card sells for that price you’ll get alerted. But you can also do it for cards you’re looking to sell. For example, if you have a rule that you’ll sell a card for double what you buy it for – you can set that price alert.
  • Check graded card ratios. You can see the ratio between PSA 9s and 10s of cards to see opportunities with grading.

The price point can be a tad expensive for some – $25 a month for the basic plan, and around $50 a month for the pro plan.

There’s also a yearly plan where you only pay for 10 months. 

But I guess that really depends on how you look at it.

If you’re not really taking your cards seriously and just buy the odd card here and there, then these features might be a little more than you need. However, if you’re managing a card collection worth thousands of dollars and you’re always looking to buy/sell – then, for me, $50 a month to make sure you can keep track of everything mentioned above is a no-brainer…. Just the man hours alone that you’ll save is worth it.

Out of the two, I 100% think the Pro plan is the best price. Everything else in the Lite plan can be done for free (with a little more elbow grease and a lot more time).

Like I said though, it really depends on what you’re after. If you’re just casually collecting cards then I wouldn’t bother – but if you want to keep track of sales prices over time, set price reminders, and all that other good stuff, then I’d give Market Movers a try.

You can try Market Movers out here. And make sure you use the code SCR20 to save 20%.

Best Free Option: Sell The Peak

When I quickly want to find card sale prices, I use Sell The Peak.

The cool thing about this tool, is that it actually gives you sales prices and not listed prices (more on that later, but basically if you price search on eBay – it’ll show the sale price for a “best offer” item as the original listed price and not the actual sale price).

The free version of Sell The Peak is really cool and lets you search for eBay items:

From there, it’ll bring up all the recent cards that fit that search, giving you actual sales prices.

I’m a big fan of the ease of use with Sell The Peak – and if you quickly need a sale price, it’s a good option.

Other Ways to Check Sport Card Prices

Check eBay Sales Prices

eBay is still the biggest marketplace to sell your sports cards. Because of this, they’re a great resource if you want to find rough sales prices for your cards.

However, as you’ve probably noticed, almost every seller lists their cards and boxes at inflated prices. There’s two reasons why sellers do this:

  1. The most important reason is that there’s room to negotiate with buyers
  2. Every now and then, some idiot will just pay the ‘buy it now’ price and pay huge overs (don’t be that idiot)

Because of this, it is important to make sure you click the ‘sold items’ option when checking prices. That’ll only show you items that have sold.

Once you only search for sold items, you get a clearer idea of the prices that your cards have sold for recently.

However, there is one problem with eBay’s sold prices…

When you search for sale-prices of cards on eBay, there is one problem. eBay won’t show you a negotiated price. So, if a buyer and seller negotiate a price, it’ll list the ‘but-it-now’ price that the seller initally listed and not what the card actually sold for.

So, make sure you pay extra attention to the cards that sold via auction – that’s a far more accurate way to check sale-prices.

Visit PSA Price History

PSA also have a great database of card sales that you can access for free.

When you do, you can search for a specific card or even a specific set. When you search for a card’s prices, you’ll be able to check the PSA grading, the sales price, the date, and where the auciton was held.


There’s even a cool graphing tool that shows your card’s sales as a line graph to show the growth of the card’s price over time.

The graph is a handy tool to check and see if you can cash in a card while it’s hot.

Beckett Price Guides

Beckett’s price guides is another great resource that you can use to check the prices of your card collection – along with getting a good look at the market as a whole.

The data on Beckett is arguably the best online, however it isn’t free – there’s a small monthly membership you’ll need to pay in order to access their data.

It’s really up to you if you think it’s worth it to pay for Beckett price guides. My view is, if you’re an investor, it’s a well worth the money – you’ll make that $9 a month back pretty easily by making wiser buying choices.

But if you you’re just looking to get a rough price estimate on a few old cards you’ve got hidden in some shoe box in your old childhood bedroom, it’s probably not worth it.

Other Tools and Retailers

More often than not, eBay and PSA will give you a decent-enough idea on your card’s prices. However, there are some other handy tools that you can check out.

One site I use a bit is StarStock, if you’re familiar with sneaker collecting, you may have heard of it before. Well, they do cards too, and they have a decent enough collection now where you can look at card sale prices.

StarStock is one of those platforms that let’s buyers put open offers for cards along with sellers listing their cards – so you get a good picture on what people are willing to pay for a card like yours.

But, What if I Can’t Find Sales History For My Card?

One issue you may come across when looking for past sales data is not being able to find much history for your card.

  • You can’t find the same player
  • You can’t find the year/make of card
  • You can’t find cards with the same grading

Don’t worry, that’s pretty common. There won’t be comprehensive sales data for every single card.

Instead look for cards similar to yours and make calculated guesses. For example, if you have a PSA 10 graded card and can only find sales data for PSA 9 versions of the same card – then yours will be worth more than that.

If you can’t find your player, then look to see other players of similar stature and see what they’re selling for. Yours will more likely sell for a similar price. The same goes for the year/make of card – find something similar and work it out from there.

Also remember that rookie cards are worth more. So if you can only find sales data for rookie cards and yours isn’t one, then yours will almost certainly be worth less.

Sure, it’s not perfect – but it’s a hell of a lot better than nothing.

What Sports Cards are Worth Money?

It doesn’t matter if you’re looking at baseball cards, basketball cards, football cards, soccer cards or anything else – the formula for card prices is pretty much the same.

These are the factors that’ll alter price:

  • Star Players: It shouldn’t be any surprise that the cards of start players are worth more than the cards of lesser-known players. Or, in other words, Michael Jordan cards are worth more an Luc Longley cards (not to me, I love you, Luc).
  • Rookie Cards: A player’s rookie card will almost always be thier most valuable card. Think of it this way, it doesn’t matter how many seasons a player is in the league – they’ll still only have one year of rookie cards. The added scarcity makes the card more valuable.
  • Brand: There’s a bunch of different card brands and designs. Each different sport will have different brands that are on top. The type of card you’ve
  • Print-Run of The Card: For example, if your card is only printed to 50 (there was only 50 of that card ever made), that will be worth more than a card printed to 250, or just a regular base card. This will be printed on the card somewhere (usually the front). It’ll say how many cards were printed, and what number card yours is. For example, 010/250 means your card is the 10th printed out of the 250 in existance.
  • Publication Year: Some cards were over-printed. This means they’re not as rare as other cards of the same player. This is common in what’s called the ‘junk wax‘ era – which is the late 80s – early 90s, where cards became super-popular.
  • Graded Cards: Getting cards graded will increase their sale price. If you want to know more, you can check out this guide to card rating.

There’s also a few other factors that may alter card grades like known misprints, oddities, etc… However, they’re more the exception than they are the rule.

For most of you, those factors we listed above will be what dictates the price of your card.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s The Best Way to Price Baseball Cards?

If you’re looking to price your baseball cards (or any other sports card), check the recent sales data and price yours in that range.

Keep in mind, most buyers on eBay and other marketplaces will try and negotiate a price – so feel free to add a little extra to the ‘buy-it-now’ prices.

Is There a Market for Sports Cards?

Yes, there is still a huge market for sports cards. Now that people can buy and sell online, it’s really opened up the market to more people.

Card prices have shot up throughout the last few years as the market grows. However, it’s important to know, like any market it does correct itself from time to time.

Are Sports Cards a Good Investment?

Deciding if sports cards are a good investment for you is a tricky one. You do need to know a lot about the sports you’re collecting to be able to buy underpriced cards. The market is also quite tricky to navigate from time to time.

The payouts can be huge though, and offer far greater returns than other investments. However, with the volatility of the market, you shouldn’t replace conservative investing strategies with card collecting. Basically, don’t invest more than you’d be okay to lose. 

It definitely pays to be a collector and an investor as opposed to just an investor.

What Now?

Now that you know how to price sport cards, how can you use this information?

  • You can look to buy cards at a good price
  • You can sell cards when they’re selling for the highest price
  • You can see the prices of the cards that you’ve had in your childhood bedroom after all these years.


  • Vince

    I'm a big time sports nerd, with soccer being my first true love. I've been collecting sports cards since I was a little kid, and now... well, not much has changed, but I write about it... and I have facial hair.

A note to our visitors

This website has updated its privacy policy in compliance with changes to European Union data protection law, for all members globally. We’ve also updated our Privacy Policy to give you more information about your rights and responsibilities with respect to your privacy and personal information. Please read this to review the updates about which cookies we use and what information we collect on our site. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our updated privacy policy.